Top 10 Watermelon Classic 5K Female Performers Since 2021
Rankings based on the GOAT Index, which combines age-graded performance and field dominance across all race years.
#1 — Kelsey Shumate
Years: 2021, 2022, 2023 | Age range: 27–29 | Total Points: 91.43
Shumate took the overall female win in 2021 with a 19:35 — her fastest and highest age-graded effort (71%) — then returned in back-to-back years to finish 3rd and 2nd female respectively. Remarkably consistent across all three appearances.
Point Breakdown: Speed Score: 49.54/50 · Dominance Score: 29.88/30 · Participation Score: 12.00/20
#2 — Andre Guedez
Years: 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025 | Age range: 28–32 | Total Points: 90.65
Guedez has been a model of consistency, hovering between 23:28 and 24:14 across four of her five races with age-graded scores tightly clustered around 59%. Her best performance came in 2022 (23:28), and she’s shown up year after year as a reliable top-20 finisher in an increasingly competitive field.
Point Breakdown: Speed Score: 42.10/50 · Dominance Score: 28.55/30 · Participation Score: 20.00/20
#3 — Nancy Min
Years: 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025 | Age range: 58–62 | Total Points: 88.23
Min has run all five editions of the race, and her age-graded scores (61–65%) are genuinely impressive relative to her peers.
Point Breakdown: Speed Score: 45.29/50 · Dominance Score: 22.94/30 · Participation Score: 20.00/20
#4 — Audrey Mayatte
Years: 2023, 2025 | Age range: 16–18 | Total Points: 87.86
The youngest runner in the top 10. Mayatte debuted at 16 with a 21:40 (3rd female) and returned two years later at 18 to post a 19:15 — a 2:25 improvement that earned her 2nd overall female and her best age-graded score of 72.6%.
Point Breakdown: Speed Score: 50.00/50 · Dominance Score: 29.86/30 · Participation Score: 8.00/20
#5 — Dorothy Wofford
Years: 2021, 2025 | Age range: 37–41 | Total Points: 87.21
In 2021 she finished 3rd female at 20:09 with a 71.2% age-graded score. Her 2025 return was a solid 22:01, good for 10th female and a 67% age-graded score. The gap between appearances makes the consistency impressive.
Point Breakdown: Speed Score: 49.63/50 · Dominance Score: 29.58/30 · Participation Score: 8.00/20
#6 — Elisabeth Gaillet
Years: 2021, 2023, 2024, 2025 | Age range: 25–29 | Total Points: 87.11
Gaillet has shown clear improvement over her four-year span. She debuted in 2021 with a 24:57 (55.7% age-graded). Her 2025 result in a field of 442 females underscores her growing competitive standing.
Point Breakdown: Speed Score: 42.48/50 · Dominance Score: 28.62/30 · Participation Score: 16.00/20
#7 — Jessica Diamond
Years: 2021, 2022 | Age range: 33–34 | Total Points: 85.89
Diamond put together back-to-back performances in the early years of the race that were nearly identical — 20:57 and 21:03, finishing 4th female both times, with age-graded scores of 67.2% and 67.1%.
Point Breakdown: Speed Score: 48.25/50 · Dominance Score: 29.64/30 · Participation Score: 8.00/20
#8 — Kara Hankins
Years: 2021, 2024, 2025 | Age range: 37–41 | Total Points: 85.54
Hankins has appeared across a wide span of years with solid times. Her 2021 debut at 37 (22:32, 12th female) remains her best raw time, though her age-graded scores have been comparable across all three races (~60–64%). Her standout result by field position came in 2024 when she finished 5th female in a field of 347.
Point Breakdown: Speed Score: 44.67/50 · Dominance Score: 28.87/30 · Participation Score: 12.00/20
#9 — Savannah Turner
Years: 2023, 2024, 2025 | Age range: 40–42 | Total Points: 85.42
Turner entered the race in 2023 and has improved her relative standing each year — dropping from 15th to 12th to 17th female in raw position, but finishing in a progressively larger field. Her best age-graded score came in 2025 (63.6% at age 42), and her raw time of 23:23 that year was also her fastest.
Point Breakdown: Speed Score: 44.59/50 · Dominance Score: 28.83/30 · Participation Score: 12.00/20
#10 — Catherine Holmes
Years: 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025 | Age range: 58–61 | Total Points: 85.25
Her best year was 2023 (64.9% age-graded at 59), and she is notably consistent.
Point Breakdown: Speed Score: 45.45/50 · Dominance Score: 23.80/30 · Participation Score: 16.00/20
Here is the full breakdown: Watermelon Classic 5K Run - Female Rankings